Dr. Michael Sonnleitner
I run the risk of trying to cover too much information today. In this topic, I am fairly expert—not because I’m a scientist, but because I’m a political activist. I have been teaching international relations for as long as I’ve been teaching about Gandhi, for nearly 50 years. Part of international relations, at least during my era of life, has involved climate, climate change, global warming—many concepts that might be confusing to you.
While the focus today is on fossil fuels and COP 31, I found it best, based upon my experience, to assume that at least some of you know almost nothing. I know that in my normal classrooms over the years, that is a normal and good assumption. I want to begin relatively slow and build up. We will get to Turkey. We will get to COP 31. You will know what COP means. We are people from every continent, though I don’t know if we have anyone from Australia. We are people of one world.
We don’t need to know what the exosphere, thermosphere, and all these spheres are, except that they’re all surrounding one sphere, which is oblong and not entirely round. And we call it Earth, Mother Earth, Gaia. It is the planet upon which we live. The planet has layers of atmosphere. The exosphere is up to 1,000 kilometres into outer space, and there are a total of six layers.
Now, rather than get into this in depth, I would like you just to imagine the sun’s rays coming into the planet through the atmosphere. That is what warms us. That is what fuels us. That is what gives us life, among other things. There is something called the ozone layer. It’s a tiny, thin little layer which is just above the troposphere. The ozone layer is about 12 kilometres—about 5 miles—out from the surface of the planet. We have come to know that the ozone layer is a critical layer that protects us from the ultraviolet rays of the sun.
It’s really the UV rays that come in and warm the planet. We need ultraviolet radiation to warm the planet to keep us above freezing. The ozone layer, however, filters this UV radiation. If there was no ozone layer, the UV rays would come in and, yes, warm the planet, but it would also blind all eyes. It would blind us all. From cows and chickens to squirrels to human beings worldwide, we would have no capacity to see.
It would burn all crops if there was no ozone layer. It would fry the planet. The worldwide temperatures might not be too high, but the ultraviolet rays would burn. That’s how you or I get a sunburn if you have a lighter complexion. If I’m at a high altitude where I’m closer to the ozone layer, perhaps in a place like Lake Tahoe in the United States, the temperature can be quite cool, but I might burn. My skin would burn. This has happened. I remember it very clearly.
The ozone layer is crucial to life. And we were destroying the ozone layer through producing a chemical called chlorofluorocarbons. We learned in the 1960s that this man-made substance, which was used in air conditioning and aerosol sprays and a variety of really wonderful consumer products, would float up into the ozone layer and create holes. And this was a crisis. We could destroy life on the planet simply by destroying the ozone layer.
Now, I’m not going to dwell on this too far, but I want to start with a note of optimism before we get all depressed, because the world saw—we saw, we weren’t blind yet. We saw this danger to the ozone layer, and there met, called by the United Nations, a meeting in Montreal, Canada, in 1987, and the world’s nations came together to ban chlorofluorocarbons—the Montreal Protocol of 1987. The world came together, banned the production and use of chlorofluorocarbons, and saw the danger it posed to all of humanity worldwide, all life on the planet.
We created other substances that did not do the same harm for our air conditioning and other purposes. Today, there are virtually no refrigerators in the United States using CFCs, no air conditioners using CFCs, no aerosol spray cans with CFCs—none of this. It has been banned, and the United States has agreed to it, and we are leading the way with other countries to stop this threat to life on the planet. And good news: now, decades after 1987, the ozone layer is healing itself.
The planet is coming back into balance. This is no longer a threat to life. Keep this in mind when we go to Turkey and we see what is happening with climate change there. It can be depressing. But remember Montreal. Remember that it is possible for humanity to wake up and to see the dangers it faces, and to act together as one humankind.
The greenhouse effect takes place when the sun’s rays come to the surface of the planet. The ozone is protecting us from UV radiation, but the heat of the sun still gets through. To the extent there is a blanket around the planet, that blanket will keep us warm. We need that blanket. The sun’s rays come in, heat the Earth, heat the rocks, heat my skin, and then they bounce off the surface of the planet. Some of that heat goes into space, and some of it is kept by the greenhouse blanket. That is what causes global warming. Remember, we need some warming or we will simply freeze. Rather than fry, which the ozone layer protects us against, we would freeze if there was no blanket.
If the blanket is too thick, then the heat becomes too great. The blanket is caused by various greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide, and methane. We’ll get back to that. Most folks focus on carbon dioxide because it is the most plentiful in that blanket. Sulphur dioxide comes from places like coal burning and volcanic eruptions. Methane comes from decomposing matter, from sources like cow manure or decomposing vegetation—which happens when we put in a dam, for example, for hydroelectric plants, flooding an area and creating a large amount of methane. In places like the United States, where we grow a lot of meat, beef, and poultry, the excrement can be in such large supply that it creates a lot of methane. The bottom line is: the thicker the blanket, the more heat is trapped, and the warmer the surface of the planet is. That is what is causing global warming. We need some, but not too much. It’s a very fragile balance.
Notice that the sun’s rays come in directly toward the equatorial regions, the middle part of the planet, more directly than toward the polar ice caps. The middle of the planet gets warmer, while the polar ice caps, Antarctica and the Arctic, receive more indirect heat. They will get warm, but not as warm. Where the sun’s rays hit directly, it’s going to be hotter. Where they hit indirectly, more at a slant like at the North Pole, it will warm, but not as much. There is a gap, then, between how much the Earth’s surface is heated. The gap is the difference between the equator and the Arctic.
Now, some of my students get confused. They say, “Well, I can understand global warming, but what’s climate change?” Climate change is a result of the greenhouse effect and the sun’s rays hitting at different angles in different parts of the planet. There may be a hot air mass around Mexico, and a much colder air mass up in northern Canada. It’s still warmer than it would have been, but it’s colder. The gap between Mexico and the north of Canada is great. The greater the gap, the greater the storms. The colliding of the cold and hot air masses creates turbulence.
The greater the gap, the greater the hurricanes, the greater the tornadoes, and the greater the strength of typhoons in the South Pacific. It seems a little strange that global warming would have different climate effects in different parts of the world. In North Africa, it will expand the Sahara Desert. And yet in places like Oregon, where I live—which is a mid-latitude, almost midway between the equator and the North Pole—it will result in greater rainfall and flooding. So, it affects weather patterns worldwide in different ways.
The overall average heat of the planet may increase, but with dramatically different impacts on the surface of the planet depending upon whether you are close to the equator or closer to the North Pole. The greenhouse effect causes climate change. Donald Trump observes this and says, “You say it’s getting warmer. I say it’s a hoax because we’re having colder winters in some parts of Canada. So global warming makes no sense. It’s getting colder in some places.” Trump can’t grasp this impact of global warming upon climate change. I’m hoping you can, and I’m hoping I haven’t confused you.
From Mr. Trump’s perspective, it’s all a hoax, a myth. That’s why he took the United States out of what he calls “the scam that was the Paris Climate Accords.” His perspective is: “We want to have industrial development. We want to bring manufacturing back to the US. We want to drill, baby, drill more oil. We want to burn, baby, burn, create more jobs. Climate change and global warming is a myth. It’s a hoax. It’s fake news.” You can see how people who cannot grasp the difference between global warming and climate change get very confused. And that’s the best I can say of Mr. Trump: he’s very confused, and it has a horrible impact upon many people throughout the world.
Now, let us turn to the Earth’s six major mass extinctions. We’re going to get a little bit more depressed; I’ll just warn you. But this is nature. Before human beings were around, we were having this issue. Species became extinct, and new species came into being. This is nature’s way of simply evolving.
Many, many millions of years ago, the Earth did largely freeze over, and 85% of the species at that time died. A second mass extinction took place with 75% of species becoming extinct. A third, during the Triassic period, saw 95% of species become extinct. Each had different causes—extreme cold was the first cause.
Changes in the acidity of the oceans, where most life lived, was the second cause. A third cause involved the changing of the continents moving. We once were all together as Pangaea, as you may know, and gradually over time the continents moved to where they are now, which appear to be very far apart, though once we were all together.
The Jurassic period extinction was caused by volcanic eruptions, releasing a lot of sulphur dioxide particularly into the atmosphere, causing dramatic increases in the greenhouse effect and global warming that killed many, many species. The fifth great extinction was, by all accounts, caused by a meteorite that hit the Yucatan Peninsula near Mexico. It caused a massive cloud of debris that went worldwide and seriously cooled temperatures because the debris in the atmosphere prevented the UV radiation from warming the planet. Effectively, 75% of life as we then knew it died.
Now we’re in the sixth extinction. We’re in it. It’s happening now. The sixth extinction, by all accounts, is primarily human-caused. It’s industrial society, a dramatic increase in population, destruction of habitat, and increased carbon, sulphur dioxide, and methane in the atmosphere creating greater heat. This is causing many fragile species to become extinct. This began perhaps 50 years ago and is ongoing.
To give you an idea of the current extinction, we can look at a few facts that are sobering. As of 1975, about 50 years ago, there were 16 million plant, insect, and animal species known to exist on Earth. There may be more, but there were 16 million in 1975. Today, there are 8 million. Already, we’ve had a mass extinction involving 50% of the species of life on the planet. And this coincides with a dramatic increase in carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases affecting the warmth of the planet and creating climate change.
We’re down to 8 million species. COP 17, which relates to the biodiversity convention, met recently in September for its 17th year, and they are predicting that we will have 1 million more species dead by 2050, and 2 million more extinct by 2100. And who knows how much more severe the extinction will be? It depends largely upon us. We’re creating this mass extinction by the way we live. We’re reaping what we sow. It is karma.
It is part of our industrial way of life, if you want to call it that. Gandhi would say, “Industrialize and perish.” He didn’t know about global warming and climate change, but he knew about perishing. He knew that we would reap what we might sow. From 1975 to now, we have killed half the species on Earth, and we’re continuing to escalate. That is the climate emergency. That is what people like Greta Thunberg describe as the climate emergency.
She is one of my favourite climate activists. She’s now 23 years old. At a young age in Sweden, she began a one-person movement outside the parliament, aware of global warming and its impact upon this mass extinction. She went every day after school to plead for the lawmakers to act. Today, she’s known worldwide. She has been nominated for several Nobel Peace Prizes, though she’s too radical to win any of them. She is, to me, an inspiration. Take note of her name, Greta Thunberg, and find out about her on your own.
She has inspired young activists worldwide to express themselves. And I might add that she has what we might call a disability, though it’s a strength: Greta Thunberg has autism. She is brilliant of mind, though in her case, she is not very socially aware. She has a hard time communicating with people. She doesn’t always see their body language. She doesn’t always understand their emotions.
She is like a logic machine. She is brilliant. She sees what is the truth, and she holds firm to the truth. Does she sound Gandhian? Yes. She holds firm to the truth as she sees it: “We’re killing the planet. We’re killing the planet.” She doesn’t care what people think about her because her autism prevents her from really processing what other people might be thinking about her. She doesn’t get their emotions. She’s immune from criticism. She simply speaks what she believes to be right.
And she is at COP 31 in Turkey now, for the first time in five years. The last Conference of the Parties that she attended, she made headlines because, as a teenager, she looked at the deliberations and was asked, “Well, what do you think about this, Greta? What do you think about these world leaders coming together from 190 countries of the world—these 50 and 60,000 people coming together to express their concern about climate change? Greta, what do you think about it?” Her response was: “Blah, blah, blah.”
We’re going towards a mass extinction which affects our own food supplies. It’s not just about the monkeys and the fish. It’s about us not having enough food in the future to sustain us. These people are captured by the oil interests, by the fossil fuel industry. They’re meeting together for show. They’re telling us how much they care, and they are not doing anything. Blah, blah, blah.”
When I heard that, I thought, she’s speaking the truth. “Blah, blah, blah” is mostly what we’re talking about. The UN conventions create all sorts of wonderful frameworks. They can see the danger, but they’re not really creating any enforceable policies to act against the dangers. “Blah, blah, blah” is a great summary. We must go beyond “blah, blah, blah” to action.
Now, let us understand what COP is, focusing on fossil fuels and COP 31. COP 31 is happening now. What is COP? There are many COPs—that’s confusing—and many of them are interrelated, though they meet in separate conferences. They all serve as the supreme governing and decision-making body of the conventions or treaties that they are seeking to enforce. A Conference of the Parties simply means a conference of those countries who are signatories of the conventions and treaties that they’re trying to enforce. They’re parties to the treaties.
In this case, COP 31, which is meeting in Turkey in the city of Antalya, is the 31st annual meeting or conference of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, the UNFCCC. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change was created 31 years ago—that is why this is COP 31. It’s the 31st annual global convention seeking to increase enforcement of what? The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change includes both the Kyoto Protocol and the Paris Accords.
Briefly, the Kyoto Protocol of 1997—created 10 years after the Montreal Convention helped resolve the ozone depletion problem—set binding targets for 37 industrialized countries to reduce greenhouse gas emissions—that’s carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide, and methane—by 2012 to an average of 5% below 1990 levels. Kyoto was signed in 1998, but didn’t come into force until 2005, nearly a decade later, when Russia signed. You can see that these treaties are negotiated, they’re signed, and typically they don’t come into effect until enough countries ratify them. So, there’s already a massive lag on coming to an agreement and then actually trying to enforce it. It sounds like “blah, blah, blah” to the people who want action.
The Paris Accords were from 2015. They replaced the Kyoto Protocol, and they entered into force in 2016. 195 countries signed, agreeing to set their own voluntary emission reduction targets. These are known as NDCs—Nationally Determined Contributions. And already you can hear what Greta is saying. You can hear what she is thinking: “Voluntary. We have voluntary greenhouse emission reduction targets. Wonderful. 195 countries are going to voluntarily reduce carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Wonderful. And they’re going to submit new plans every five years. And they’re going to report on their progress. Wonderful.” You can hear her sarcasm. In a sense, it is wonderful that we can come to those agreements. But to people like Greta, it’s just more “blah, blah, blah.” We need action. We’re facing a species extinction event. We’re in it. We can’t just talk about it unless we want it to go on and grow deeper and worse.
What is the aim of Paris Accords? The accords sought to create a climate-neutral world by 2050, limiting global warming to below 2 degrees Celsius, and preferably 1.5 degrees Celsius. Currently in 2026, 11 years after the Paris Accords, the globe is at 1.5 degrees. We have reached the limit of global temperature increase that Paris was designed to prevent us from reaching. And we’re looking, by all accounts, at going beyond 1.5 degrees. We will probably go beyond 2 degrees, and we can see the impact: again, species extinction. Let’s not forget it.
According to Greta, myself, and many others, this is a climate emergency, and we’re not acting as if it’s an emergency. “Our house is on fire,” Greta Thunberg would say. And yet, we’re still in the house. We haven’t even gotten outside the house yet. It’s burning. And yet, we’re meeting in Turkey. Delegations from over 190 countries are there. They reached their destination using 90 chartered jets, bringing delegations in private, chartered jets—again adding to global warming through the burning of fossil fuels just to get there. And Greta’s saying, “Blah, blah, blah.” She’s there this time, and she’s going to be a very vocal part of the discussions. She’s not a delegate; she’s a protester.
When we look back at the history of our planet, we are reminded of past mass extinctions and the fragility of our environment. Looking at annual carbon dioxide emissions—just one of the greenhouse gases produced by burning fossil fuels like oil and natural gas—the trajectory is alarming. In 1900, global output stood at two billion tons of CO₂. Back then, the world was in the Industrial Age, though not yet heavily into it.
By 2023, however, emissions had climbed precipitously, turning the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere into a mountain. Today, China is the number one emitter, producing more carbon dioxide than any other country on the planet. The United States held that top spot for a long time before China overtook it. Currently, federal leadership under Mr. Trump is pushing policies that risk putting the U.S. back in that position, as the nation is failing to curb its carbon dioxide emissions effectively.
Meanwhile, India contributes 8.1% of global greenhouse gases, and that share is increasing dramatically. The rest of Asia, from Vietnam to Japan, accounts for 12.6%, the Middle East stands at 8.3%, and Russia is at 3.0%. Europe accounts for 8.4%, and after growing dramatically in the past, its emissions are now actively decreasing. Europe—and especially Germany—is significantly reducing its carbon dioxide output. They signed the Paris Climate Accords, set strict emission standards, and are meeting their goals.
This success comes down to strong public awareness and a powerful green movement. The Green Party in Germany is the strongest of its kind in the world; even with around 10% of the vote, they remain extremely prominent as both protesters and policymakers. As a result, Germany is leading the way in renewable energy. China is also leading in renewable deployment, even while remaining the top carbon emitter. In the United States, emissions have largely stabilized, though this is no thanks to federal policy. Instead, it is driven by local action—led by figures like Governor Newsom of California, the nation’s largest state with 40 million people—alongside many other cities and states working independently to cut carbon emissions.
Looking at the broader picture of global carbon emissions, output rose by 1% between 2021 and 2022 alone and continues to project upward. While the United States remains mostly stable and the European Union is in decline, China’s dramatic surge has made it the top emitter, and India is rising rapidly. Between 1960 and 2020, India increased its carbon emissions by 6%, expanding its share of the greenhouse blanket at a faster rate than even China. While India’s overall total is still lower than that of China or the U.S., its percentage growth outpaces the rest of the world. In an effort to catch up with China’s GDP, India is burning oil, natural gas, and coal as quickly as possible—a path that harms the global climate and runs counter to the values of figures like Gandhi.
Sulphur dioxide, on the other hand, offers somewhat of a success story. Primarily caused by burning coal, global sulphur dioxide emissions are steadily declining as the world reduces its reliance on this dirty fuel. International efforts, such as the annual UN Conferences of the Parties, are making a measurable difference. However, regional exceptions remain a serious concern: sulphur dioxide emissions are still rising dramatically in the Middle East and increasing significantly in India, showing that key areas are still not conforming to the global downward trend.
Methane, or CH₄, presents another major challenge. It stems from wastewater, landfills, livestock excrement, and rice cultivation, particularly as the chaff decomposes after harvest. Currently, methane emissions are increasing in Russia, China, India, the United States, and Brazil. This is critical because methane is 10 times more potent than carbon dioxide per unit, making it one of the most severe drivers of greenhouse warming.
Ultimately, our industrialized rush to development is still overwhelmingly powered by fossil fuels: 28% coal, 34% oil, and 25% natural gas. By comparison, hydroelectric power accounts for just 3%, nuclear power for 5%, and other renewables—including solar, wind, and geothermal—make up only 6%. While renewable energy is growing, overall consumption remains dominated by fossil fuels, and the global transition is happening far too slowly to satisfy climate advocates like Greta Thunberg. Across the entire global energy supply, renewables account for just 5.6%. Finally, it is worth taking a brief moment to examine the drawbacks of nuclear and hydropower—because while nuclear energy is clean when compared to fossil fuels.
“Looking at the questions Michael raised, I think Greta Thunberg would definitely call the COP 31 ‘3535’ goal ‘blah, blah, blah.’ Reaching 35 percent electricity production by 2035 sounds nice on paper, but if that electricity is still coming from coal, oil, or nuclear plants, it completely misses the point. Real climate action isn’t just about switching to electric grids—it’s about how we generate that power and who controls it.
When we look at the data—like the last few years shattering global heat records—it’s clear we are in a climate emergency. Yet, globally and locally, we aren’t acting like it. In wealthier nations, our policies are still built around protecting high-consumption lifestyles rather than making systemic changes. Meanwhile, the people who contribute the least to the problem, like communities in the Global South or those displaced by massive dam projects, pay the highest price.
Neither Greta Thunberg nor Mahatma Gandhi would be pleased with where we are. Greta has repeatedly called out world leaders for offering vague future promises instead of immediate fossil fuel phase-outs. And Gandhi, who championed local self-reliance and simple living, would strongly oppose centralized megaprojects that harm ecosystems and marginalize the poor.
If we actually want to treat this like an emergency, we need to shift government subsidies away from fossil fuels and nuclear energy, and put them directly into decentralized, community-owned solar and wind power—while seriously rethinking our own consumption habits.”
Feedback from Group Discussion
Moderator: Most of us are back. We would love to hear from the groups about what happened in your discussions through your feedback.
Group One: I think the answer to the main question is no—they do not have sufficient ambition to avoid “blah, blah, blah.” What our group brings to the table is that we need to focus on the individual level, the government level, and all other layers to ensure things happen, and if they don’t, we need to take action. I think that is the brief summary of my group. Well, in addition, we concluded that there is not enough sensitization, education, and self-awareness for people to act. And even where there is, there is this nonchalant attitude among all of us. So, there is no sufficient ambition—it is only “blah, blah, blah,” and that is all.
Group Two: We paid more attention to the idea that at the individual level, every person should put effort into addressing climate change, and the government should also put effort into driving climate solutions.
Group Three: We also discussed developed versus developing countries, and how the same rules cannot apply to both because conditions are different. I heard in one speech External Affairs Minister of India saying that we are trying to take care of 1.6 billion people. That is a very tall order, and developing nations have to pursue whatever means they can to lift people above the poverty line. We cannot expect the same rules to apply to them as to the US or Canada.
The discussion focussed on how to keep progressing forward as much as possible. Because of internal population shifts—where people move from one place to another due to floods or other disasters—that also affects climate change. There are so many variables, and the solutions are going to be different in each situation. I want to add one more thing: I felt that it is not right to have voluntary compliance. Countries should get together and set mandatory targets, otherwise nobody is going to follow through, and there should be consequences for failing to meet them. Thank you.
Group Four: We discussed that first, from Gandhi’s perspective, whatever we are doing for climate change or energy should reach the last person in the country—the lowest economic category. The challenges we discussed include supply chain issues in managing energy, greed, and financing. Second are government policies; for example, in India, there is suddenly a cap on subsidies, and now the government says they will only take energy generated during the daytime, with a cap on the units they will reimburse. So, the government is not clear and changes policies frequently. Meanwhile, in countries like Syria, due to war, there is fuel and electricity scarcity. Everyone is putting solar on their buildings and using solar energy, but again, there are financing issues—not all individuals can afford it. Finally, there is a political angle where some developed countries dominate developing countries and exploit them regarding energy, and as Greta mentioned, there is a capitalist lobby influencing all these fuel and energy decisions. So those are the points we discussed. Thank you.
Concluding Remarks: Of course, mandatory targets are a good idea, but they tend to be difficult in an international system that has no enforcement capacity. We make a rule—say, against war crimes or genocide—and there is no consequence. We will, of course, be discussing Israel and Palestine next week.
Basically, despite the fact that we have different realities in different parts of the world, we are still one ecosystem. What affects one directly affects all indirectly. Martin Luther King Jr. was right: if the United States continues to produce greenhouse gases, it creates climate change in Africa. Everyone contributes to everyone else’s reality. Inspired by Gandhi, I think it is important for us to realize that yes, we need to live by personal example, my family needs to live by example, my village needs to live by example, and my region needs to live by example. We are returning to Swadeshi, right?
Decentralized energy production is much more likely to be controlled by the people rather than large corporations. Consider the difference between generating wind power through a small windmill on your farm versus massive turbines spread over acres of land owned by a large electricity company. There is a big difference. Gandhi would suggest: think locally, build locally, act globally—decentralize, decentralize. This is anti-corporate.
I am trying to get my state of Oregon to agree not only to provide energy production systems at a low or subsidized cost for every small business and home in the state, but also to connect them all to the electricity grid. If I produce more electricity at home than I need, I can be paid for it. In other words, we decentralize production so it is not controlled by large corporations. This is not impossible; it is a matter of will. In Africa, we have the technology, though not so much the financial resources yet.
There needs to be capital provided by COP 31 and other major conferences to redistribute the means by which we improve our lives from wealthy countries to poorer countries. There needs to be a transfer of the means to produce electricity and stability for our common good. It is in the self-interest of wealthy countries to help poorer nations avoid burning coal and fossil fuels, which increases global warming and affects everyone, including the wealthy countries. We must help one another.
Gandhi is relevant—can you see it? Swadeshi and Swaraj are extremely relevant, and a global green movement—not necessarily a political party, but a movement—is necessary to preserve what we can from this sixth global extinction. We need to act now. That is a sober tune, but we can do it. I hope that you can be inspired by Greta and others to see that change is possible locally and globally.
Hi, this is a comment.
To get started with moderating, editing, and deleting comments, please visit the Comments screen in the dashboard.
Commenter avatars come from Gravatar.